Laura L. Cooper - Author
Sign up for RSS feed
  • Home
  • Stories & Articles
  • Updates
  • Biography
  • Pursuit of Justice Blog
  • Missing Children

Pursuit of Justice Blog

"I think the first duty of society is justice."
--Alexander Hamilton

FACEBOOK AUTHOR PAGE

Cameras on Cops: The Questions They Raise

12/4/2014

5 Comments

 
Picture
Clipping a body-worn camera onto every law enforcement officer won't solve all our current issues, and it will raise new ones.

Last year, I wrote a blog that focused on the possible benefits of the technology:
  • Document evidence in investigations
  • Protect citizens from excessive force
  • Defend officers from false accusations

After the controversial use of force case in Ferguson, Missouri, there is an outcry for all law enforcement officers to wear cameras. The White House wants millions of dollars invested in the effort (Dann and Rafferty). However, not every community is prepared to cope with the questions raised by this technology.

Questions We Must Ask
  • When will the cameras be set to record?
  • How will video footage be stored? For how long?
  • Who decides when video data will be released to the public?
  • What if the recording device malfunctions?
  • How will the presence of cameras affect victims, witnesses, and suspects?
  • How will the privacy rights of officers and the public be protected?

Body-worn cameras open up tremendous possibilities for documentation and transparency. My concern is that they could be used to trample privacy rights, try suspects and officers in the media, scare off victims and witnesses, and micromanage every aspect of law enforcement.

We must prepare policies and public expectations so that we protect privacy rights, set reasonable procedures for officers, and realize that every technology has its limits.

Video Footage

Agencies must be clear about when and how cameras will be used and share this with the public. We cannot record everything...not officers undercover, in a briefing, or at the urinal.


"No one wants to talk to you if everything is being recorded," said Larry Ellison, president of the Massachusetts Association of Minority Law Enforcement Officers" (Johnson and Smith).

Public Release

We need to assure victims and witnesses that their videotaped comments are not subject to public records requests. But can we? Suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty, so video may need to be protected until it is used in court. The public should not expect that everything recorded today can be released on the Internet tonight.


Limits of the Technology


It is important to realize that as helpful as the technology can be, it will not resolve all issues. There will be times a camera malfunctions, records blurry images, or is turned off during an unexpected event. An editorial in Scientific American points out that "even when video images are available, they are not always conclusive." Not everyone who views footage will come away with the same determination.

Moving Forward

Some police agencies have been using body cameras for years. Others are still experimenting on a small scale. Of 254 departments surveyed that use body cameras, The Police Executive Research Forum found that one-third have no written policies on their use (Hermann and Weiner).
This is bad news for police and communities.

Carefully crafted policies and laws need to direct when and how video is captured and released to the public. We cannot jeopardize court cases or privacy rights to appease the public's appetite for information. Video has a valuable place in our justice system, but how far can it go toward building trust in communities?


Resources:

  • Board of Editors, Scientific American, "Cities Want Cops to Wear Cameras...," November 18, 2014.
  • Cooper, Laura L., LauraLCooper.com, "Body Cams: An Instant Replay for Law Enforcement," October 17, 2013.
  • Cooper, Laura L., The Nebraska Sheriff Magazine, "Body Cams: An Instant Replay for Law Enforcement," January 2014.
  • Dann, Carrie and Andrew Rafferty, NBCNews.com, "Obama Calls for Police Body Cameras in Wake of Ferguson," December 1, 2014.
  • Edwards, Jonathan, JournalStar.com, "Ferguson Brings Cops' Body Cams into Focus," November 29, 2014.
  • Hermann, Peter and Rachel Weiner, "Issues over Police Shooting in Ferguson Lead Push for Officers and Body Cameras," Washingtonpost.com, December 2, 2014.
  • Johnson, O'Ryan and Erin Smith, Officer.com, "Boston Brass, Union Fear Body Cameras," December 3, 2014.
5 Comments
G. M. Barlean link
12/4/2014 06:04:10 am

I think pros and cons have to be put before everyone so the discussion can be balanced. I also think negatives can always be found. I want to make steak for my family for dinner. Wait. What if I burn the steak. What if it's too rare for some and too well done for others. How am I going to season it? So many choices. What if someone chokes on a bite of it. Maybe we should set rules about how big the bites can be. Maybe I should cut it up for people so I can control how big the bites are.
But then again, I'm a rule-breaker personality type.
There's a middle ground that can be found. I think cameras need to be considered, but I agree... that's not the real problem here. This is a social issue and it's not going to go away soon.

Reply
Laura L. Cooper link
12/4/2014 12:08:45 pm

I agree that we can't have a rule for every possible situation. There does seem to be big expectations placed on these small little devices to solve big human relations problems. Maybe it is a step in the right direction.

Reply
Laura L. Cooper link
12/4/2014 12:15:27 pm

BTW, if you're serving steak, I'll be over...no matter what the rules are :)

Reply
Faith Colburn link
12/4/2014 09:35:13 am

Thanks for this thoughtful post. I'm not sure how we make our militarized police departments accountable, but the cameras can't do it all.

Reply
Laura L. Cooper link
12/4/2014 12:25:57 pm

I appreciate your comment, Faith. Maybe if this is one part of a larger long-term project, some of our fractured communities will begin to see progress.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Laura Cooper lives in Nebraska and writes crime fiction and a wide range of short stories from her family farm.

    Categories

    All
    Capital Punishment
    Cisd
    Clemency
    Constitution
    Crime Prevention
    Crime Victims' Rights
    CSI
    Democracy
    Dna
    Domestic Violence
    Empower
    Evidence
    Fbi
    Fingerprints
    Freedom
    Half The Sky
    Hate Crimes
    Hostages
    Humor
    Jessica Ridgeway
    Justice
    Law Enforcement
    Liberty And Justice
    Lineups
    Mental Wellness
    Missing Persons
    Murder
    National Day Of Remembrance
    Nebraska
    NET
    Pardons
    PBS
    Public Safety
    RAINN
    RAINN Day
    Sentencing
    Sexual Assault
    Sexual Harassment
    Sexual Violence
    Shift Work
    Social Media
    Suicide
    Supreme Court
    Terrorism
    Thanksgiving
    Use Of Force
    Veterans Day
    Victim Impact Statement
    Victim Rights
    Women's Rights

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from DVIDSHUB, Abi Skipp, mrlaugh, MrCornfed, reborg, Luigi Rosa, carterse, 3 0 d a g a r m e d a n a l h u s, Matthew Wilkinson, leinadsimpson, Elvert Barnes, Mr.Thomas, Katie@!, Justin A. Wilcox, abraham.williams, Sue Waters, DonkeyHotey, Demon Brigade, srqpix, steakpinball, quatar, Ariane Middel, emily snuffer, Kátia :), midiman, Mr.Thomas, Mikey Angels, blvesboy, A Gude, Holding Steady, auntjojo, folkstone42, conner395, danesparza, USAG-Humphreys, Newtown grafitti, ewan traveler, mou-ikkai